hi julie, thanks for replying to my post,i have checked the 1871 census janet does not show on it,as you say janet was born 1852 as was georgina, im maybe way off the mark here, but maybe janet changed her name to georgina ?, georgina gave birth to illigimate daughter in 1872 naming her janet,one other thing i found strange,georgina married richard black 1880 they had a son richard who later married and had 5 daughters,2nd daughter born they named georgina,4th daughter born also shows on birth ce rt as georgina,but the name janet has been added,also on birth cert says clarification of childs name see reg of cor entries,as i say i might be wrong with my thoughts on this, but strange how janet seems to have disappeared and georgina appears. regards billy