There is an error somewhere. Or an incorrect assumption? Starting again from this marriage:
NSW Marriage V1853226 85/1853 PALMER GEORGE - MUTTON ELIZABETH A - IG= Wesleyan Methodist Bathurst, Hill End
I, George Palmer do hereby declare that I am a Member of, or hold Communion with, the Wesleyan Church [signed] George Palmer
I, Elizabeth Ann Mutton do hereby declare that I am a Member of, or hold Communion with, the Wesleyan Church [signed] Elizabeth Ann Mutton
I, Samuel Wilkinson, of Bathurst, Minister of the Wesleyan Church, do hereby certify that George Palmer, of Bathurst and Elizabeth Ann Mutton, of Bathurst, were joined together in Wedlock by me on the First day of June 1853, at Bathurst, in the presence of Mr William Mutton of Wattle Grove and Miss Ann Palmer of Bathurst.
Witnesses signed. [signed] Samuel Wilkinson Minister
NSW Death 7965/1906 PALMER GEORGE - GEORGE - MARY A - BATHURST
The Daily Telegraph (Sydney) - Mon 13 Aug 1906 p.1
PALMER.-At Ethelton, Bathurst, on the 9th inst., George Palmer, aged 76 years
NSW Marriage 1387/1862 MUTTON EDWARD HENRY - PALMER ANNE - BATHURST
NSW Death 1975/1875 MUTTON ANNE - GEORGE - MARY A - SYDNEY
Parents would be George Palmer (but which one ???) and Mary A Baylis.
NSW Bap V1830518 14/1830 PALMER GEORGE - GEORGE - MARY A
Baptisms solemnized in the Parish of Bathurst in the County of - in the Year 1830
No. 96 When Baptised: 1830 Augt. 22 When Born: 1830 July 13 George - George Palmer & Mary Ann Baylis his wife Abode: Bathurst Plains Quality or Profession: Settler By whom the Ceremony was performed: John Espy Keane