The 1851 & 1861 not helpful, take your point about the 1823 Catherine..
1871
Registration Number: 685/2
RD: St Andrew
Parish: Edinburgh St Cuthberts
Address: 54 Cumberland St
Ref: ED: 78; Page: 6; Line: 21; Roll: CSSCT1871_160
Henry Hastings 51
Catherine Hastings 48
James Grant 28, Hiram Whitney 35, Mirtress Whitney 24, J H Shirley 40
Geoff