Jane or John or both MALCOLM

[DaveHam9]

1861
Registration District: Blythswood
Civil Parish: Glasgow Barony
County: Lanarkshire
Roll: CSSCT1861_105 Page 9
ED: 64
Address: 47 Renfrew St
William Malcolm 35 Stone Mason Largs Ayrshire
Jane Malcolm 35 Mauchline Ayrshire
Robert Malcolm 12 Glasgow
Archibald Malcolm 8 Glasgow
Elizabeth Malcolm 5 Glasgow
Jane Malcolm 2 Glasgow ??
Rebecca B P Malcolm 1mo Glasgow

1871
Registration No: 644/1
Registration District: Central District
Civil Parish: Glasgow Inner High
County: Lanarkshire
Roll: CSSCT1871_124 Page 13
ED: 62
Address: 23 Weaver St
Wm Malcolm Head 44 Stone Mason Largs Ayrshire
Jane Malcolm Wife 44 Ayr Arshire
Arch Malcolm Son 19 Stone Mason Glasgow
Eliz Malcolm Dau 17 Calenderer Glasgow
John Malcolm Son 11 Scholar Glasgow ??
Rebecca Malcolm Dau 8 Glasgow
Jessie Malcolm Dau 7 Glasgow
Willie Malcolm Son 5 Glasgow
Alex Malcolm Visitor 25 Fereman Largs Ayrshire

Jane or John or both ??

Dave

 

[horse]

No images to double-check, possible..

Jane Malcolm
Birth Date: 22 Mar 1859
Birth Place: Blythswood
Father: William Malcolm
Mother: Jane Malcolm
FHL Film Number: 6035516

Nothing obvious for John without checking images on SP, there are a few possibles.

Geoff

 

[horse]

Neither with the family in 1881.

Geoff

 

[DaveHam9]

Thanks Geoff.

Naming patten is out.

Elizabeth - 1st daughter - mother's mother - ok Elizabeth Davidson
Jane (Jean) - 2nd daughter - mother
Rebecca - 3rd daughter - father's mother - ok Rebecca Wylie

A death for Jane 1861 - 1871 ? No death that fits. Only this one

MALCOLM
JANET ROSS
3
GRAHAM
1864
622/2 409
Springburn

Dave

 

[DaveHam9]

Thanks Geoff.

Nothing that fits for birth for John as 11 in 1871. Two deaths in Lanark

MALCOLM
JOHN
11
1871
644/9 1197
Tradeston

MALCOLM
JOHN
10
1871
644/7 492
Milton

William MALCOM & Jean MALCOM
26 Nov 1847 Glasgow, Lanark, Scotland
Batch: M119675

 

[horse]

Ages a bit too close to make any reasonable assumptions, that said there are 2x births in Blythswood [Jane's PoB], but there are others in Glasgow

MALCOLM JOHN
1858
644/6 48
Blythswood

MALCOLM JOHN KIRKWOOD
1859
644/6 489
Blythswood

Middle name may or may not be useful even to eliminate..

Geoff

 

[DaveHam9]

Thanks Geoff.

Wylie and Bain and Porterfield and Yeats on William's side.

Davidson and Porterfield and Yeats on Jean's side. Don't know past Davidson. No baptism or death for Elizabeth Davidson.


Real problem. Either John is missing in one and Jane in the other or John should be Jane in 1871.

Dave

 

[DaveHam9]

Rebecca Brown Phillips b. 10 Mar 1861 Blythswood, Glasgow, Lanark
William MALCOLM & Jane MALCOLM

No idea where those middle names come from.

Dave

 

[horse]

Interesting Rebecca also b. RD Blythswood… More consistent than the naming pattern

Geoff

 

[DaveHam9]

Not normal pattern.

1st son Robert - mother's father
2nd son Archibald - father's father
3rd son William - father

John would not fit but pattern is not the usual for sons or daughters.

Dave

 

[DaveHam9]

I'll save my credits for deaths etc not census records.

Back in about 1 hour Geoff.

Dave

 

[horse]

OK, Dave.. Speak later.

Geoff